What we Know about Jonah Magnus (1816-1867)

So I decided to compile everything we know about Jonah Magnus' backstory. My sources are a blend of cannon and historical sources, given that two of his letter writing associates are actual historical architects and Millbank prison is a real place. I will try to stay away from any unfounded headcannons (Though if you've read my fic about Jonah in this time period you may see where I drew events from)

I shall list chronologically first what we know from cannon and then what we know from Smirke and Millbank's historical records.

In 1816 we know he has made an association (left vague- the relationship is clearly pleasant but the nature is unclear) with a German man named Albrecht von Closen. At this point Jonah has developed a "fascination for the macabre and strange" Closen tells Jonah of the tomb full of books and the eyeless (ghost?) of Würtemburg. At this point we know Jonah Magnus is likely an adult, putting his birthday at some point prior to 1798.

In 1818, Jonah Magnus establishes the Magnus Institute. It is unclear if he serves the Eye yet at this time.

In 1824 Jonah Magnus let Barnabas Bennett succumb to the Lonely. (Whether or not you subscribe to the "they were dating" is up to you, I personally don't). By this point we know Jonah has (is about to) begin serving the Eye. We also know that he knows Mordechai Lukas and is on "good terms" with him.

On the subject of Lukas, we know that it is Likely that Smirke introduced Jonah to "Lukas, Scott, and the others". It is possible that he brought Lukas to Smirke but less likely than not due to location and class concerns.

Smirke's gatherings of people he brought into his confidence took place decades before Jonah killed him as evidenced from his letter "but I feel I must break the silence that has characterized our acquaintance for these past few decades" and his reluctance to bring anyone else into his confidence since. His gatherings contained at least Lukas, Scott, and two other people in addition to Magnus. All of them fell to one power or another.

In 1831 Fanshawe writes to Jonah, informing him of Closen's death. Closen at this point was almost certainly a follower of the Eye, but did not wish to be. We also discover Jonah, at some point, stole the books from Closen, through a scheme involving his favorite bookbinder, resulting in Closen's death. We also get confirmation in this statement that Millbank is up and running and needs a doctor.

In 1841 we learn that George Gilbert Scott has begun serving the buried. And that Jonah Magnus made yet another associate involved in architecture, Sampson Kempthorne.

Now this point is purely speculation and an interpretation from different statements. But in 1853 Simon Fairchild attempted a ritual that failed. Jonah may have played a role in its failure. He states in his statement "At first, I attempted prevention, but the cause seemed hopeless". Simon's ritual failed because of a hunter but Jonah Magnus is not exactly someone who likes to get his hands dirty.

In 1867 Jonah Magnus kills Robert Smirke through some ritual of the Eye that has everyone stare at him.

The exact date of the first Watchers Crown is unknown but we know it failed. Sometime after that he switched bodies (likely using some knowledge from Würtemburg's library given his lack of eyes)

Historically we know that Smirke (1 October 1780 – 18 April 1867) was a well connected Tory darling with a fondness for Greek architecture. He was well known for his influence on greek revival architecture though he dabbled in other styles as well. He had a wife named Laura whom he married cerca 1819 and a daughter, also named Laura. He was also described as able to please "men whom it was proverbially impossible to please". I could spend a very long time listing all of his works.

Millbank is a complicated matter historically- Smirke didn't really do that much with it, just some remodeling. However this is analyzing the podcast not history.

What we do know about Jonah in this time period was that he was "getting older, and mortality began to weigh more heavily on my mind. How much in this world is done because we fear death, the last and greatest terror?" We also know the reason for his current ritual were power and immortality so clearly he has some significant fear of the End.

However, the fact of the matter remains that this is the podcast's titular villain. And all we know about him are a handful of letters and some scraps of information. Why do we have more statements devoted to the Distortion than we do about Jonah Magnus? Or Gerry? (No diss to either character). But he's mentioned as many times as Jared Hopworth and is a significantly more important character to the narrative.

More like this

Can we appreciate the genius that is Elias starting an institute to gather paranormal statements? It’s on the same par as if Jon had started a therapy practice. Other avatars feed in such complex ways, but Elias didn’t have to do anything. People came to him, willingly letting him feed.

The fandom’s complete mischaracterization of Elias/Jonah never ceases to enrage me

i like how often elias says "be seeing you" lmfao

Elias' whole dealio is very silly to me. haha guys look at how much my humanity has slipped look at how much of a monster I am *does actions motivated by a deeply human hurt and commits logical fallacies only feasible for someone who feels a terribly human type of fear*

I'm sort of continuing my TMA relisten (skipped the Prentiss attack because I didn't feel like listening to it at the moment) and I've got something to say about the MAG 42 supplemental and Jon's paranoia.

Fans consistently joke that Jon being suspicious of Martin's behaviour was stupid and entirely irrational and "stupid paranoid idiot, Martin's being attentive to your needs because he has a crush on you!" But you have to take into account Martin's very impressive (and entirely fake) resume, as well as him turning out to be quite resourceful during the Prentiss attack despite being previously bad at his job, not to mention the ominous unfinished letter he left behind that said he's worried about the others "finding out that he's been lying" - if I were Jon then I would sure as HELL be suspicious of him too. Also you need to remember the very likely possibility that Jon never really had many people care for him before (on the account of him being orphaned from an early age and his grandmother disliking him etc etc so. What might be obvious and logical to YOU doesn't necessarily have to be that obvious to HIM.)

It's strange that so many fans dismiss the thought of Martin putting up a front and pretending to be incompetent as completely impossible when he straight up admits to having done just that in S5. Yeah he didn't kill Gertrude, and he was bad at his job cause he lied on his resume, but that doesn't mean he's the world's most honest man cmon

I finally finished the last chapter of season 2 (at least the first draft because it is in dire need of editing lol).

Jon is so annoyed the entire time and fair enough. He does find out that Gerry beat up Leitner though and finds that very amusing.

Anyway, we’ve been doing a lot more thinking for season 3.

I am going to wreck Martin’s mental health so bad and I feel bad for him already. Like by the end of s2 he’s already struggling, and I’m going to make him so much worse in s3. Actually, I’m making everyone worse in s3.

I’m also hoping to do more original statements for s3. I kinda get an excuse to due to plot differences anyway, so I think it would be fun. I do really enjoy writing statements, so I just need to figure out what I want to do and I’ll have some fun. I just need to go through and see which statements are plot relevant and see what I’m left with. I may also change around which avatars Sasha meets with, but I’m not 100% sure yet.

Anywho, I am trying so hard not to spoil what I do in s2 since we’re so early on when it comes to me posting. I want to yap about it, but I don’t want to ruin the surprises. I am having so mcuh fun with this fic though.

I'm at MAG 22 in my relisten, and it got me thinking a bit about the fandom's certainty that Jon absolutely despised Martin's guts.

I'm pretty sure Jon's dislike of Martin was only ever prompted by the man's utter incompetence and didn't extend much further, considering how he offered Martin a room in the archives without any hesitation whatsoever. Jon's far more caring than most people give him credit for

Sponsored